Background Checks and the Gig Economy: Are Businesses at Risk?
Table of Contents
- The Rise of the Gig Economy: A Double-Edged Sword
- Key Risks for Businesses Hiring Gig Workers
- Essential Background Checks for the Gig Workforce
- Industry-Specific Screening Considerations
- Balancing Speed and Security in Screening
- Protecting Your Business in a Changing Workforce
- Resources to Strengthen Your Screening Process
The Rise of the Gig Economy: A Double-Edged Sword
The gig economy is booming. With platforms like Uber, Deliveroo and Upwork facilitating on-demand work, freelance and temporary roles are becoming the norm. According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), the UK’s gig economy workforce doubled between 2016 and 2022, with over 7.25 million people now engaging in some form of gig work. While businesses benefit from cost savings and workforce flexibility, they also face new security and compliance challenges.
As gig work becomes more mainstream, companies must rethink their hiring strategies. Unlike traditional employees, gig workers often operate independently, making it difficult to enforce company policies or ensure consistent background screening. Additionally, the rapid nature of gig employment, where workers are hired and deployed quickly, creates vulnerabilities that bad actors could exploit. Without the right screening measures in place, businesses may unknowingly expose themselves to legal, financial and reputational risks.
Key Risks for Businesses Hiring Gig Workers
Unlike full-time employees, gig workers often bypass traditional hiring processes, leading to increased risks such as:
Fraudulent Applications
Without thorough checks, businesses may unknowingly hire individuals with falsified qualifications or histories. A 2023 CIFAS report found that identity fraud in job applications increased by 43% in the UK (CIFAS Fraudscape Report, 2023). Given the rise of online work and remote contracts, fraudulent applicants can more easily manipulate resumes, misrepresent credentials or use fake identities to secure employment.
Regulatory Non-Compliance
In industries like Healthcare, Education and Finance, hiring a gig worker without the correct background screening can result in severe legal penalties, financial losses, and reputational damage. For example, the Care Quality Commission (CQC) requires that all healthcare staff, including temporary workers undergo stringent screening. Failure to meet these compliance standards could lead to fines, litigation or even the loss of operating licenses.
Data Security Breaches
IT Freelancers and remote gig workers often access sensitive company data, making it crucial to screen for past cyber offenses or fraudulent activities. According to the UK Government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey, 39% of businesses reported security breaches in the past 12 months, with external contractors being a growing risk factor. Without proper vetting, businesses may expose themselves to data leaks, intellectual property theft or ransomware attacks.
Customer and Workplace Safety Risks
Roles involving public interaction such as delivery drivers, private tutors and ride-share drivers, require safeguarding measures to prevent potential misconduct. Neglecting background checks in these sectors could result in businesses unknowingly employing individuals with a history of violent behaviour, harassment or criminal activity. This not only poses a direct safety risk but could also lead to significant legal and reputational repercussions in cases of misconduct.
Essential Background Checks for the Gig Workforce
While traditional employees undergo comprehensive screening, gig workers often fall outside of standard HR policies. To mitigate risks, businesses should consider the following checks:
DBS Check (Basic, Standard, or Enhanced depending on the role)
Essential for gig workers in sectors involving vulnerable individuals or sensitive information. A Basic DBS check is suitable for lower-risk roles, while Standard or Enhanced checks are necessary for positions involving children or at-risk adults.
Right to Work Verification
Ensures compliance with UK immigration laws and prevents employment fraud. It is the responsibility of the employer to confirm that gig workers have the legal right to work in the UK to avoid penalties and potential legal action.
Digital ID Verification
Confirms identity authenticity, reducing the risk of identity fraud. With an increasing number of gig workers being hired remotely, digital ID verification provides a fast and secure way to confirm the worker’s identity before onboarding.
Employment & Credential Verification
Confirms work history and qualifications, particularly for high-risk sectors like Healthcare and Finance. Employers should verify previous job roles, certifications and any professional memberships to ensure candidates have the necessary experience and expertise.
Overseas Criminal Record Check
Crucial for workers with an international employment history. This check helps employers identify any criminal activity in a candidate’s home country before hiring, ensuring they meet safety and security standards.
Financial & Fraud Screening
Recommended for gig workers handling sensitive financial data or transactions. Screening for past financial crimes, bankruptcy or fraud history helps businesses reduce the risk of insider threats and financial misconduct.
Industry-Specific Screening Considerations
Different industries require tailored screening approaches. Here’s how background checks should be adapted:
Healthcare & Social Care
Enhanced DBS checks are non-negotiable to ensure patient safety when working with children and vulnerable adults. Additionally, Right to Work verification, Employment Screening, Adult First checks and Overseas Criminal Record checks are often necessary for those who have previously worked abroad in the medical sector.
Technology & IT
Right to work checks, Fraud screening and Digital Identity verification help protect company data and prevent insider threats. Given the rise in cyber threats companies should also consider cybersecurity background assessments and Professional Certification validation.
Education & Tutoring
Enhanced DBS checks, Prohibited from Teaching checks, and Qualification verification are crucial for safeguarding students. In addition, a Section 128 check should be carried out for a person in a management position in an independent school, academy or free school as an employee; a trustee of an academy or free school trust; a governor or member of a proprietor body for an independent school; or a governor on any governing body. Schools and tutoring agencies must also conduct periodic rechecks to ensure continued compliance with safeguarding regulations.
Transport & Delivery Services
Right to Work verification, Driving Licence checks and Basic DBS checks are essential for ensuring public safety. Employers should also conduct periodic DVLA checks and drug/alcohol screening where applicable, especially for those in passenger transport services.
Financial & Legal Services
AML (Anit Money Laundering), PEPs & Sanctions, Financial Background screening, Qualification verification and fraud checks reduce the risk of financial crimes and misconduct. Companies should also consider regulatory compliance checks such as FCA approval verification, to ensure that workers meet industry standards.
Balancing Speed and Security in Screening
One of the biggest challenges for businesses hiring gig workers is finding a balance between fast onboarding and thorough screening. A lengthy screening process can deter gig workers, yet skipping essential checks exposes businesses to risks.
How to Streamline Gig Worker Screening:
- Use Digital ID Verification – Modern tech allows instant verification of candidate identity, reducing processing time.
- Leverage the DBS Update Service – If gig workers already have a DBS check, subscribing to the update service allows real-time monitoring.
- Implement Tiered Screening Based on Risk Level – High-risk roles (e.g., Healthcare, Finance) require stricter checks, while low-risk roles may only need basic verification.
- Partner with a Trusted Screening Provider – Working with an experienced background screening provider like Checks Direct ensures compliance, efficiency and accuracy in verifying candidates.
Protecting Your Business in a Changing Workforce
The gig economy presents incredible opportunities but also unprecedented risks. Businesses must adapt their hiring and screening processes to ensure compliance, security and operational integrity.
By integrating tailored background checks, leveraging technology and maintaining ongoing compliance monitoring, companies can safeguard their workforce while embracing the flexibility of gig employment.
Take Action: Is Your Business Screening Gig Workers Effectively?
Don’t leave your company exposed to unnecessary risks. Checks Direct can help implement fast, compliant and cost-effective background screening solutions tailored to gig workers.
Contact Us today to safeguard your workforce and protect your business.
Resources to Strengthen Your Screening Process
Make every check count.
Keep your organisation and people safe with our independent and verified checks. Get DBS Checks for regulated activites today.